Just get on with it. Give it up. Don't let your emotions cloud your judgement or your relationship with your dog.
Okay so they just swallowed your engagement solitaire.
Peed on your favourite pair of shoes.
Chewed up a one of a kind priceless text.
Pulled you down the stairs unexpectedly, when you told them to stay, and you hurt!
Sorry react appropriately and then it is done.
No grudging allowed.
And we humans are experts at grudging. And the more it hurts the better we are at it. And that is just too bad.
Once it is done. It is done.
You might think that your puppy completely understands how upset you are especially as they cower before you, looking all so guilty. They will try to appease you.
Because the reality is they don't understand why you are mad, 5 or 10 minutes after the fact. Not even 2 minutes later.
They just see that you are upset, and that you are yelling. And the more you yell, the louder you yell, the angrier you get, the more submissive they will become.
Their submission is not about understanding and saying sorry no matter what you think. It is saying hey you are the leader of the pack and I am being submissive so you won't hurt me, I am being submissive so you will accept me back into the pack.
Doesn't matter if it was serious, doesn't matter if you still really hurt.
The grudge has to go. Really if we were perfect it should never happen.
The yelling, the name calling, the anger… think about it, if they don't understand, all you are doing is being a bully and damaging any trust between you. Not only for today but for the future.
So how is this different then the two minute concept? That is a teaching mechanism, to help develop a specific skill. To assist with focusing. You might be think well is the puppy not focused by my yelling? By how upset I am? Oh definitely. But the focus isn't on what he did, it is a focus on what you are doing.
Because he feels threatened. Think about the yelling. The intent behind the yelling. The message behind the cursing. The anger. And there is always a threat. Veiled or otherwise.
"But damn that hurt."
I feel for you. I really do. Been there.
And I am sorry but…
From a training, communication perspective was your response relevant, proportional, appropriate?
The dog really doesn't care about a shoe, but you do.
The message is supposed to be don't touch anything that isn't yours to touch, eat or play with. Obviously the training isn't complete, you need to revisit that training and you might need to do some puppy proofing in your home. If you have not finished the training, that you can trust him, then what the heck were you doing not watching him to make sure he would behave, and how silly were you to leave your shoes where he could get to them.
"Well what about him tripping me on the stairs?"
Not good, definitely needed a verbal reprimand. Quick, sharp and commanding. Perhaps he needs the "talk".
It is about communication, training, and trust - not punishment. This is not about making them feel bad, it is about making sure that they do what we designate as right. What we tell them should be their behavior. We want our choices to become their choices. This is not about bad or good, it is about them fitting into our lives and acting the way we want them to behave.